| Cooper Jeffcoat - Oak Mountain HS | 1:53.54 | 1:54.07 | ( 0.53 ) |
| Ian Chatterton - Hoover | 1:55.38 | 1:59.05 | ( 3.67 ) |
| William Peterson - Central - Tuscaloosa | 1:56.54 | 1:54.22 | 2.32 |
| Malachi Carroll - Haleyville High School | 1:56.83 | 1:55.43 | 1.40 |
| Jackson Mize - Vestavia Hills HS | 1:56.95 | 2:00.40 | ( 3.45 ) |
| Caleb Price - Florence High School | 1:57.34 | 1:55.32 | 2.02 |
| Preston Barnes - Northridge High School | 1:57.68 | 1:56.24 | 1.44 |
| Braden Little - Mountain Brook HS | 1:57.74 | 2:01.78 | ( 4.04 ) |
| Caleb Johnson - Bob Jones | 1:57.87 | 1:57.68 | 0.19 |
| Ryder Linville - Scottsboro HS | 1:58.20 | 2:06.71 | ( 8.51 ) |
| Mitchell Schaaf - Vestavia Hills HS | 1:58.26 | 1:56.35 | 1.91 |
| Cole Smith - Providence Christian School | 1:58.27 | 1:58.22 | 0.05 |
| Hudson Rukstalis-Williams - Mountain Brook HS | 1:58.38 | 1:55.05 | 3.33 |
| Jackson Allen - Huntsville HS | 1:58.41 | 2:04.01 | ( 5.60 ) |
| Nehemiah Johnson - Hazel Green | 1:58.45 | 1:58.07 | 0.38 |
| Travis Barnett - Holly Pond | 1:58.53 | 1:54.75 | 3.78 |
| Daniel Deleon - Fort Payne | 1:58.53 | 2:04.43 | ( 5.90 ) |
| Pablo Rodriguez - Fort Payne | 1:58.61 | 1:57.08 | 1.53 |
| Estan Wrights - St. Paul's Episcopal | 1:58.65 | 1:59.58 | ( 0.... |